False witnesses in Vlad Filat’s case
Three women from the Russian Federation, who seem not to know about the situation in Moldova, appear as key-witnesses in the resounding corruption case involving Vlad Filat. According to statements made by Ilan Sor in court, they would have brokered alleged bribery worth 320 million lei to former Prime Minister. These statements were accepted by the court and included in the sentence without inviting the youths for evidence. Center for Investigative Journalism found the names of these girls and contacted two of them. The girls claim that they have never beento Moldova and do not know Ilan Sor and Vlad Filat.
Irina’s account worth millions at Unibank
Irina Alexandrova is an ordinary girl from Moscow. According to socialisation sites, the 27 year old girl is fond of photos and cats. He works in a bank in the capital of Russia, goes out with friends and she loves cooking. In Chisinau, Irina's name appears in one of the most sensational criminal cases in Moldova's history. The businessman Ilan Shor reported that he would have sent to Vlad Filat with the help of Irina Alexandrova, a part of the bribe of 320 million lei, money that would have been asked by former prime minister for various services.
Reporters of the Center for Investigative Journalism obtained two orders of issuing cash, which show that in spring and summer of 2014, Irina Alexandrova withdrew 850,000 euros from a subsidiary of Unibank in Chisinau. According to the first bank document, on March 5, 2014, Irina withdrew from her account at Unibank 150,000 euros (2.8 million lei), and on August 4, 2014, she withdrew from her account 699 300 euros (13 million lei). Subsequently, this money wastransmitted to Vlad Filat.
„I have never been to Moldova ”
I contacted Irina by phone to learn more about her involvement in the corruption case in Chisinau. She replied immediately, but asked us to call her back in the evening, when she finishes work. "I am at work and I cannot talk. Can you call me back later? After 19.00, please", Irina told us kindly. Later, the young girl blocked all calls of CIJM reporter and did not answer to any other calls from other phone numbers in Moldova. In a phone recording that came into our possession, Irina claims that she does not know Ilan Shor and Vlad Filat and she has never been to Moldova. "I do not know any local banks or citizens of Moldova. I have never visited Moldova", says the girl.
Fragment of phone conversations with Irina Alexandrova
The same operator withdrew money from Unibank on March and August 2014. Vlad Filat's defenders suspect that signatures on bank documents issued on behalf of Irina Alexandrova and of other two citizens were forged. "There are sufficient grounds to assume that these signatures are forged. We will request a handwriting analysis. To this effect, we must collect signatures from these people in the Russian Federation. This can be done through a rogatory letter sent to the Russian Federation ", said lawyer Igor Popa.
„Ilan Shor? A singer?”
Alina Papikyan is the youngest of the "accomplices" invoked by Ilan Shor. She is 26 years old and lives in Moscow. I contacted her by phone to discuss about the criminal case. "I've never been to Moldova. Ilan Shor? Is he a singer? ", asked the girl. After I explained that her name appears in a criminal case, stating that she sent bribes worth several million dollars to former Prime Minister Vlad Filat, Alina said "Is it a nightmare? I do not remember talking to anyone about this case. I do not remember, maybe I sent my documents to someone, but I often lost my documents. Which bank accounts in Moldova? I save money. What you say, is fantasy", said Alina Papikyan, worried that she might have problems because of this story involving her that happened behind her back.
Phone conversation between the CIJM reporter and Alina Papikyan, girl from Moscow who appears as intermediary in the transactions between Ilan Shor and Vlad Filat
The last alleged accomplice of Ilan Shor in transmitting money to Vlad Filat is Larisa Noscova from town Tveri, Russian Federation. Larisa, 38 years old, seems not to be involved in the banking system. The girl provides services of eyebrow styling and tattooing. I wrote on a social network to ask her if she knows Ilan Shor and Vlad Filat and if she ever sent money to former Moldovan PM. Larisa did not reply.
“Censored” witnesses in the sentence
The names of threegirls from Russia appear in the justified sentence in Filat’s case, published truncated by Buiucani Court. The court decision refers to the fact that Ilan Shor would have sent to Vlad Filat through Irina Alexandrova, Larisa Noscova and Alina Papikyan, 320 941 414 lei. Every time, these sums of money came into Vlad Filat’s possession after this money was withdrawn to these girls from the accounts which they owned at Unibank.
"The amount of 500,000 euros, withdrawn on 20.5.2014 from the account of XXXXX, at the request of XXXXX, which under the exchange rate of NBM in local currency is 9.440.000 MDL", reads the document. According to court, this is the scheme by which citizens from Russia came into possession of the money which was sent to Vlad Filat.
In all, under the court decision, in the period May 17-December 12, 2014, these 3 girls from the Russian Federation went 34 times to the bank to withdraw the money. The sentence refers to the sum of money which was transmitted by Irina Alexandrova on August 4, 2014.
The sentence was dictated in the absence of hearing by judges of any of these 3 girls. Buiucani judges rejected the request of lawyers for bringing these witnesses in court.
Orders to cash release in the name of IrinaAlexandrova, Larisa Noscova and Alina Papikyan, mentioned in Buiucani Court judgment of June 27, 2016
Fake bank documents?
Center for Investigative Journalism sent a request to Border Police to find out if the three women from the Russian Federation visited the Republic of Moldova in the past 5 years. By publishing the article, we did not receive a reply from the institution. A similar request was sent to the court. The lawyer of former Prime Minister Vlad Filat, Igor Popa says that in the reply from border police, magistrates announced that these persons have not crossed the check points controlled by the Moldovan Official authorities in the period November 2011 -to present.
"Since they did not come to Moldova in the period concerned, it is obvious that the documents signed by the girls at a bank in the Republic of Moldova are false and money could be indicated in bank documents and not actually withdrawn. Statements made by Ilan Shor at the prosecution stage and at court will be examined in terms of false declarations, and by refusing to submit the statements to the Court of Appeal, he denies his contribution to the discovery of the crime. These statements cannot constitute the basis of a decision of conviction, but rather a decision of acquittal ", said VladFilat's lawyer.
Requested to comment on this situation, the lawyer Veaceslav Turcan pointed that if in a case, a witness says that he sent bribes through third parties, the investigative body is obliged to question all persons involved. “Causalitymust be proved; otherwise, it’s an invented accusation. If people invoked as intermediaries deny any involvement, it is about false charges brought by Ilan Shor, and a criminal case must be initiated to this effect. This person must be retained for misrepresentation. Vlad Filat's lawyers must take measures to ensure that their client is recognized as the injured party ", explained Turcan.
Court of Appeal Chisinau washed its hands of the matter
On Wednesday, November 2, judges of the Court of Appeal examining Vlad Filat’s case, refused the request of the lawyers of former official to call a rogatory commission in Russia in order to question the three girls mentioned by Ilan Shor of having brokered bribing of former premier . The court instructed the defense to bringing in witnesses. "We made every effort that these witnesses to come to court. I had a communication with them. Witnesses have requested to be summoned before a court. We requested to senda rogatory letter on behalf of the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Moldova to the Russian Federation for hearing these witnesses. Vlad Filat was sentenced to nine years in jail based on Ilan Shor’s statements. The sentence readsthat Shor gave 320 million lei to Vlad Filat with the help of these three people from the Russian Federation. These witnesses are very important in this case", said the lawyer after the hearing held on Wednesday.
"I have not received any request for rogatory commission"
Contacted by phone, Justice Minister Vladimir Cebotarisaidthat he did not receive any request of rogatory commission on this case from the court.
"Legal practice stipulates that the court must submit the request. If we get it, we will execute it. So far, we have not received anything", said the official.
We tried to get a comment from Ilan Shor. As he is under house arrest, the businessman could not reply directly, but his lawyers saidthat under closed hearings, they cannot comment or give some feedback about the view of Vlad Filat’s lawyer. "Unfortunately, I cannot appreciate the statements made by witnesses from the Russian Federation. The status of lawyer, the closed trial process and professional ethics ban it. Everything that Ilan Shor said, was included in the public denouncement. I cannot comment on the information that is not included in the denouncement", said for CIJM one of Ilan Shor’s lawyers, Iulian Balan.
Prosecutor Adriana Betisor has not answered the phone to comment on this case. Head of Anti-Corruption Prosecutor Viorel Morari said that he could not comment on the situation because he was not head of this institution when the case was investigated. "When I came here, the case was already on trial, at the court. As chief prosecutor I cannot change the status quo, the court confirms what has been done. Moreover, the fact that you have reported thatdoes not mean this is true. We reach conclusions from materials of the criminal case. It is difficult to comment on this case because I have not seen the materials of the criminal case", said the prosecutor.
Vlad Filat was sentenced on June 27, 2016, by the Buiucani Court magistrates of the capital, to nine years in prison for passive corruption and influence peddling. Also, the court ordered the confiscation of his property. The politician was arrested based on a self-denunciation filed by businessman Ilan Shor, who admitted that he would have sent to Vlad Filat 250 million dollars for the latter to ensure conditions for developing several businesses of Shor.
Previously, 27 nongovernmental organizations, including the Center for Investigative Journalism in Moldova have signed anappeal and require judgement of case of the former PM Vlad Filat at public hearings.
"The examination of this case in public is particularly important for increasing the society trust in justice, to clarify the situation regarding the robbery of the billion and provide the right for a fair trial of persons accused in this case", reads the appeal of the civil society.
This investigation has been produced as part of the “Journalists for Integrity in Public Service” campaign, carried out the Center for Investigative Journalism with the support of the Good Governance Program of Soros Foundation Moldova. The donor does not influence the topic or content of the published investigations.
Investigations in the same category:
VIDEO // Story of a bribe for prosecutors
A "remuneration" of 235 thousand euros would have determined the Anticorruption prosecutors to stop the criminal prosecution and to release a businessman suspected of money laundering in particularly large proportions. The intermediary who filmed with the hidden camera the moment when the money was transmitted to a prosecutor, reported the case to the Anti-corruption Prosecutor's Office. The case was covered up and the complaint was removed from the record. From trafficker to creative man and patron Gheorghe Vîrtosu. Photo: virtosuart.com The businessman who was investigated by the CNA (National Anticorruption Center) for money laundering is Gheorghe Vîrtosu and lives in the
Property and interests of candidates for the seat of general prosecutor
20 candidates applied for the seat of Prosecutor General, initiated by the Ministry of Justice in late September. Among those who compete for the seat of general prosecutor are lawyers, jurists, prosecutors. Anticoruptie.md portal reveals the profile of candidates and their property. UPDATE: 4 of the 20 candidates competing for the seat of general prosecutor were not admitted to the contest. The Ministry of Justice announced that, following the evaluation of the files submitted, the Commission for the pre-selection of candidates to the office of general prosecutor admitted 16 candidates. Thus, the lawyer Ilie Rotaru, former prosecutor Ion Vicol, prosecutor of
Main state institutions, guarded by security companies with criminal past close to Vlad Plahotniuc and of “the thief in law” Makena
Two private enterprises of over 100 that ensure security and detective services gained advantageous tenders for the security of state institutions for many years. One of the companies belongs to an off-shore company, affiliated to the leader of PDM, Vladimir Plahotniuc, and the other is of a former policeman, who would be connected to the criminal authority Vladimir Moscalciuc, alias Makena. Though, these companies are targeted in dubious schemes, torture cases, use of force, illegal interceptions and other serious actions, they are free to guard public institutions, including those in justice field, despite the prohibitions of the law. The
INDICTMENT: April 7, 2009. How torturing policemen, judges and prosecutors were (NOT) held accountable
On April 7-8, 2009, when thousands of young people went out to protest against the April 5 parliamentary election fraud, and police forces were mobilized to repress the peaceful protest, hundreds of young people were detained forcefully, and taken to police commissariats, where they were humiliated and tortured. Dozens of prosecutors and judges went to police commissariats and judged the young people maltreated for mass disorder or hooliganism without taking any attitude to police atrocities. Ten years after the events of April 2009, we find that several files were closed or suspended and the truth was not revealed. Not a
INDICTMENT: April 7, 2009. Ten years of injustice
Ten years after the violent actions of April 7, 2009, following a peaceful protest triggered by the authorities, where hundreds of young people have been maltreated and tried in the police commissariats, no prosecutor, judge or policeman has ever been punished for abuses committed. Prosecutors filed 71 criminal cases, but only some of those who participated in the devastation of Parliament and Presidency buildings were punished. Just one policeman, who fled the country and wanted by Interpol, was sentenced to jail. All officials who somehow managed the actions of the police forces or were indifferent during the events of
Greek magistrates did what justice in Moldova didn’t: former international expert sentenced to 2 years in prison for pedophilia
Eight years after the publication of an investigation of the Center of Investigative Journalism about a network of pedophiles in Moldova and Ukraine, Greek justice ruled: Nick Georgiadis, one of the pedophiles abusing minors, was convicted. Tuesday, February 26, in Greece, two years in prison. In the Republic of Moldova, Georgiadis was "escaped" from criminal punishment. "The court in Athens, Greece did not acknowledge any mitigating circumstances and sentenced Georgiadis, aged 55, to a 28-month prison sentence and a fine of 20,000 euros. At the time of committing the crimes, he was advisor to the Minister of Economy within the
Judges with apartments for free
During the last five years (2012-2017), more than MDL 127 million were allocated from the Chisinau municipality budget to provide with apartments some persons who sued the City Hall asking for housing or for concluding reconciliation transactions with it. Among the beneficiaries of such apartments, but also of funds, there are also magistrates. Some of them, although they received apartments free of charge from the housing stock of Chisinau municipality, have enriched themselves in the meantime with other dwellings: some of these being purchased at preferential prices, others - bought at market price. There are also judges who have
Women victims of domestic violence, facing alone the aggressors and the justice system
Victims of domestic violence, mostly women, often depend on a justice system that does not protect them and does not show leniency when out of despair they try to defend themselves or counter-attack, say lawyers and human rights activists. Angela Gojan. Photo: CIJM Angela Gojan was just over 20 years old when her marriage became a nightmare for her. Finally, 10 years later, she decided to break the vicious circle. The woman says that she was cruelly beaten for trifles: someone looked at her, or she did not take care of the child or did not exactly meet her husband's requirements.
„50 shadows“ of the billion dollar theft cases
Every time when prosecutors are asked about the investigation of the billion dollar theft they invoke three criminal cases, and namely, "Shor case", "Filat case" and "Platon case” that have had different "fates" since the start of the prosecution. Several violations of the proceedings, excesses on the side of prosecutors and judges, ill-treatment, and human rights violations in custody and detention were reported in two of these cases. Reference to Shor, the first person concerned in a criminal case on the theft from Banca de Economii, Banca Sociala and Unibank, the case has "frozen" on the table of the
„Stemma” of justice (II)
They were colleagues at the Law faculty, and now they are acting as judges, being opponents from the post of judges, lawyers or prosecutors. Though they say that the relationships of colleagues from the period of study do not influence on their professional activity in any way, several concrete cases prove that some judges and prosecutors have been promoted just in the period when their faculty colleagues served important posts in the justice system. You can see below the university colleagues of the chairman of the Supreme Court of Justice Mihai Poalelungi, of the General Prosecutor Eduard Harunjen and of
„Stemma” of justice
They have been colleagues at the Faculty of Law and now they are acting as judges, lawyers or prosecutors. Some of these are god-parents, god-sons while others - spouses, sons, daughters, brothers or sisters. All of them claim that personal relationships do not prevent them from being objective, in a country where most citizens perceive justice as the most corrupt field. In 2013, Ziarul de Garda (Zdg) revealed how the lawyer Iurie Guriev, god father of judge Oxana Banari (Mironov) who was serving at that time at the Donduseni District Court, did not request the magistrate's appeal in a case
AUDIO, DOC // “Ghost” banker in Vlad Filat’s case
A well-known Russian banker was attracted unknowingly in the controversial case of former PM Vlad Filat. Former executive chairman of the Russian Petrocomerţ bank is accused of having met in February 2013, former general secretary of the Government Victor Bodiu and they planned to take over a part of bad assets from Banca de Economii (BEM). According to the report Kroll, taking bad loans worth about one billion lei by Roseau Alliance LLP was the first step in taking over the BEM scheme. Reporters of the Center for Investigative Journalism found the banker but he does not know anything
Apartments at low price for magistrate Oleg Melniciuc’s mother and relatives in the residential block for judges
The head of the court Oleg Melniciuc, his mother and some of his relatives will get apartments and commercial property in the residential block on the street Hristo Botev 6 in Chisinau, which is currently being built for the magistrates of Rascani District Court in the capital and for their children. The magistrate himself who initially said that, though he owned some dwellings and he would like some flats for his children, he did not buy any flat in this block, but a commercial space. The president of the Superior Council of Magistracy Victor Micu received a flat in the
18 bln USD laundered through the judiciary in Moldova since 2010 (II)
About 18 billion dollars, 17 judges, three "ghost" cases whose signatories are missing, a case destroyed and a judge unwillingly involved in the scheme of legalizing "black" money in the Russian Federation. Continuation from November 20 In the period 2010-2014, the Republic of Moldova has turned into a real "laundering" of large amounts of money from Russian Federation. The scheme included at least 17 Moldovan prosecutors who have legalized profits that would have been obtained illegally, wrote the Russian media. On the other hand, officials of the National Anti-Corruption Center say they cannot speak about “money laundering" in this case, because
18 bln USD laundered through the judiciary in Moldova since 2010 (I)
Since 2010, the Republic of Moldova became a real system of money laundering in the region through the courts. This "fame" went around the world and half of the 20 judges who dictated shameful verdicts continue to judge and "do justice" to this day. Many judges who have "legalized" black money from Russia were later on involved in scandals. However, the system does not want to "cleanse" itself and some of the judges who participated in money laundering scheme were even appointed court presidents. Copycat ordinances Schemes used by criminals for money laundering were always the same - some offshore companies in
The assets declared by judges: houses and cars at negligible costs
Most judges undervalue their movable and immovable property which they officially declare to own. The reporters of the Center for Investigative Journalismarrived to this conclusion after having examined more than 400 declarations of income and assets, submitted by magistrates for 2014. The legislation requires that in declaration of assets is indicated the cadastral estimate of the property, which in almost all cases is far below market value. For cars, the price is quoted from the contract of sale, which is also, in many cases, lower than the real one. Experts say it is a vicious practice and blame it on
The judges “with nine lives”
In the documents remitted to the SCM, Vladimir Voronin, Marian Lupu, Mihai Ghimpu and Nicolae Timofti have cautioned that those rejected do not have a place in the judiciary because they discredit Justice, are not objective, have unjustified wealth, have integrity issues, relations with businessmen conducting shady businesses. Most often, the findings were based on the reports from the Information and Security Service (ISS). Despite the arguments brought by the rulers of the country, SCM kept on position or even promoted around 55 judges. In the meantime, some of them left the system honorably taking their sins with them,
The stories from www.anticoruptie.md may be used in the limit of up to 1,000 characters. Web pages must indicate the source and link directly to the article. Print media, Radio and TV stations must indicate the source. Publishing full version of stories is allowed based on a prior agreement with the Center for Investigative Journalism. Articles published on www.anticoruptie.md are protected by the Law on copyright and related rights of Republic of Moldova.