Incompetence in public procurement costs us millions
The public money comes to be spent meaninglessly because the persons responsible for procurement don’t have the necessary preparation. The mistakes of the persons responsible for public procurement cost us millions. Due to the fact that the authorities have no capacity to conduct trainings, the specialists state they learn how to carry out a tender on the internet, and also from their own mistakes. For many of them, the development of technical specifications is like a formula from applied physics.
The investigation has been conducted as a result of a notification on the Corruption Map.
Unaware of what technical specifications look like
An error made by the administration of the Pedagogical College „Vasile Lupu” of Orhei city increased the amount of the contract for repairing the roof of a study block by over 240 thousand lei. Five participants applied for the competition announced by the management of the institution, “Lemfabric” company being assigned as the winner. The initial contract was signed for an amount of 1.793.811 lei, after which, in a month, the volume of works increased by another 241.995 lei. So, the roof came to cost over 2 million lei.
The irregularities started from the very first days. One of the building site masters had an expired license and the second one prolonged it when the works were about to be finished. So, for a month the construction has been carried out practically without one building site master. Contacted by the reporter of the Centre of Journalistic Investigations Valentina Sandul, director of the college, says she hasn’t even noticed this irregularity, because she didn’t look at the date on the license, but only that on one of them the „month of November” and on the other one – „the month of December” was written.
The range of infringements however does not end here. Thus, the works were performed without a procurement plan and the technical specifications (where all the works that should be done are detailed) didn’t even exist. The director has here a justification as well, stating that it is the first time when she organizes a public tender. „We are calling the cost estimate - technical specifications. I didn’t know certain things because it was for the first time when I organized a tender. We formed a working group, invited an expert to guide us, we looked through the respective things but didn’t know them. We went to the Ministry of Constructions and they drafted for us an Endorsement Report for the cost estimate of the bid.”
Work volume increasing according to the transferred money
Even though the additional works were important, they had not been foreseen at the beginning of the tender, because it was not known what amount the Ministry of Education would allocate, the director of the college stated. „We were told like this: First we shall see, because the money was given to us from the ministry in instalments, it was the end of the financial year, you use them and if you fit into the timeframe, we shall give you more. It was late autumn. We did not know whether it would be sufficient and if we would fit into the timeframe and make use of the money. The money came in stages. And we did the works depending on what we had got, that is why we have an additional agreement.” Valentina Sandul specifies. According to her, when the money came to the ministry, the set of documents, as well as the works were performed at the speed of the thought, so, until the New Year the roof was installed.
They didn’t have even a procurement plan
As for the procurement plan, the director claims she didn’t even have one. „We had our plan -the Plan of repairs which we submit annually to the Ministry of Education. We submitted the plan in 2013 for 2014. The 2 million were granted by the state because it was raining and the whole roof was being damaged. We selected „Lemfabric” because it was the most advantageous bid and the price was advantageous, and they had equipment, that is, they had all the conditions for constructing”, Valentina Sandul added.
Also, in the set of tender documents, the statements on impartiality and lack of conflict of interest of the working group are missing. Valentina Sandul has the same explanation: „We didn’t know”.
Incompetence generates additional expenses
The case of Orhei is not a single one in the country. Ialoveni Rayon Council increased the amount of the contract for repairing the premises by over 1 million lei, because the technical specifications had not been developed correctly. IRC concluded a contract amounting to 3947,6 thousand lei with „Getarcon Grup” LLC which had to perform construction works of an attic. In a year, an additional contract was concluded, the amount being increased up to 5, 1 mil lei. Due to the fact that the responsible persons failed to provide in the contract a performance bond for the works, there was a need for another, almost 200 thousand lei for additional repairs of the top floor of the building, which had been flooded by rain. In line with a report of the Court of Accounts, „the performance bond for the contract was not ensured by the entrepreneur, and the Apparatus of the rayon head was deprived of constraining levers in case of damage caused after the execution of some works of poor quality”.
Nicolae Secrieru, specialist at the Construction Section of Ialoveni Rayon Council claims that initially the contract provided for a provisional roof, but subsequently gave up on it because the works had to be done during the summer time. „No one thought that in that summer it was going to rain so much”, Secrieru states. Besides, initially, in the technical specifications the construction material called etalbond was not foreseen, the cost of which rose to one million lei. „The problem emerged in the process of work. Etalbon had not been included in the technical specifications”, Secrieru adds.
Unaware because they lack necessary preparation
The experts say that most of the irregularities in the public procurement process are committed at the stage of developing the technical specifications for the economic agents, and the responsible persons do not have the necessary preparation to draft the tender documents.
Several persons responsible for organizing tenders on public money state they have committed mistakes in the working process whereas this allegedly happened because they did not have the necessary preparation. While in many countries these persons benefit from specialized trainings, in the Rep. of Moldova there are no institutions to provide educational services in this field. Igor Schin, the representative of the Regional Centre for Social-Economic Development of Cahul, thinks that the economic faculties from the country should have a special course to train specialists in the field of public procurement.
They learn from their own mistakes
Several mayors form Cahul say they have learnt on the fly how to make a correct bid in the tender process. „At the beginning we made mistakes because we didn’t know how to develop the tender documents for the economic agents. We were writing that we needed butter but we didn’t show, for instance, the fat percentage and we were receiving a product which was more like plasticine than butter. The onion they brought was smaller, should I have described the diameter so as to have them bring to us a quality product?! We cannot refuse a product if we don’t like it, because the children need to be fed. We have learnt from mistakes – we must describe correctly the product we need”, Nina Munteanu, mayor of Pelinei community of Cahul, says. She believes that there should be a public procurement specialist in the mayoralties to make this process more efficient. „This specialist could be responsible also for drawing investments from the outside. At present projects of this kind are being developed by the employees of the Mayoralty who have besides this many work obligations”, the mayor says.
„It’s good that Internet exists”
Nina Munteanu states that the biggest difficulty the procurement group is facing is to develop the technical specifications, especially in case of procuring goods, services and works. For example, we had to procure furniture for the kindergarten but neither me nor the accountant and the employees of the kindergarten had the necessary knowledge in the field. We had to describe the product in such a way as to have it match all the necessary parameters for the adequate growth and development of the children. We handled it with the information we found on the internet. Thanks goodness the internet exists”, Pelina mayor says.
The problem resides in the legislation
The low degree of preparedness of the persons responsible for public procurement has been noticed also by some economic agents. Nicolae Dunas, representative of „Nico Art” company from Cahul states that often the contracting authorities face big difficulties in developing the technical specifications of some goods or services. „There are system errors and it is very important to have them solved by the persons responsible for the policies in the respective field. I cannot accept my child to be poorly fed at the kindergarten. That is why there should be a quality and price balance. The problem resides in the legislation, which is a very poor one and provides no systemic solutions”, the economic agent underlines.
The public procurement experts found that the contracting authorities make mistakes when procuring goods and services on the state money. According to Serghei Merjan, expert in public procurement, often the contracting authorities do not know how to identify the services and goods the community and institutions need. As a result, useless procurements are made and there is no money left for the services which are really needed. „Because of lack of knowledge, many authorities formulate inadequate requirements towards the economic agents - either very general or exaggerated ones.”, the expert states. Those who formulate very general requirements end up buying low quality services or works, which imply also exaggerated costs for maintenance. At the same time, the authorities that formulate exaggerated requirements towards the economic agents end up procuring goods which exceed the real needs, Serghei Merjan states. According to him, some authorities initiate and award procurement contracts lacking financial resources which would cover the total cost of the works. In these cases, it often happens that the construction objects remain unfinished, and the procured goods are not functional.
We cannot train everybody
Valeriu Secas, deputy head of the Public Procurement Agency admits that many irregularities in the procurement process occur because the procurement group lacks knowledge in the legislation in the field, which is an extremely complex one. „Each institution has a working group in charge of organizing tenders and assessing the bids, but its members lack the necessary preparation”, Secas specifies. According to him, the existence of some thousands of contracting authorities and the fluctuation of staff within the state institutions makes it impossible to have this kind of training. In 2015, the Public Procurement Agency organized only 7 training seminars for the employees of the contracting authorities and just 6 for its staff within the territorial services.
Another public procurement expert, Serghei Merjan, mentions that the contracting authorities make mistakes when buying goods and services on the state money. According to him, often the contracting authorities do not know how to identify the services goods the community or the institution needs. As a result, useless procurements are made and there is no money left for the services which are really needed „Because of lack of knowledge, many authorities formulate inadequate requirements towards the economic agents- either very general or exaggerated ones”, the expert states. Those who formulate very general requirements end up buying low quality services or works, which imply also exaggerated costs for maintenance. At the same time, the authorities that formulate exaggerated requirements towards the economic agents end up procuring goods which exceed the real needs, Serghei Merjan states.
According to him, some authorities initiate and award procurement contracts lacking financial resources which would cover the total cost of the works. In these cases, it often happens that the construction objects remain unfinished, and the procured goods are not functional.
A report drafted by the Court of Accounts on the performance audit of the public procurement system shows that the Public Procurement Agency has neither information on the number of people involved in the public procurement process within the contracting authorities nor on the training needs to ensure the efficiency of public procurement. In 2015, the Public Procurement Agency organized only 7 training seminars for the staff of the contracting authorities and just 6 for its employees within the territorial services.
The value of the public procurement contracts registered at PPA in 2014 amounted to 11538,4 mil. lei, constituting about 10,3% of the National Gross Product (111757 mil. lei). Last year the amount was of 1 884 736 705,84 lei.
The investigation has been done in the framework of the Campaign „Public Money Is My Money Too”, conducted by the Centre for Journalistic Investigations (CJI) and the Association for Efficient and Responsible Governance (AGER), within a project funded by the European Union and the National Endowment for Democracy.
Investigations in the same category:
THE BIG SHOTS OF AMBULANCES
● The Moldovan citizens will have to pay back a loan of 12 million euros from the Development Bank of the Council of Europe (CEB) following an allegedly political contract for the delivery of 168 ambulances assembled in Turkey, on the border with Syria, by obscure companies connected to the AKP party run by Turkish President, Recep Erdogan. ● The tender`s budget was increased after an exaggerated amount of quality consumables worth about 2 million lei [100,000 euros] were introduced in the specifications. ● The procurement procedures were launched three weeks after the illegal deportation of seven Turkish teachers from Moldova in September 2018. Moldovan
Only in 2017, the state institutions in the Republic of Moldova spent over MDL 74.8 million for unplanned increases in the price of public procurements made. For this reason, about 700 additional agreements on increasing the value of the procurement contracts were signed. In 2015 and 2016, the price increases approved by additional agreements amounted to MDL 222.2 million and MDL 310.3 million, respectively. According to the experts, there are several reasons why the public authorities accept this. Sometimes, these increases are justified, in other cases - these are made because of someone’s interest or unwillingness of the contracting
Perished food products with “bio” label in kindergartens in Chisinau: companies, schemes and tenders
Several audio recordings of intercepted phone calls of employees of some kindergartens, officials of the Departments of Education, Youth and Sport of Chisinau and of several businessmen have shocked the public opinion. Intercepted phone calls reveal that small children in kindergarten were supplied with perished food products. Names of the persons involved are kept in secret by investigators who pretend to fear for the safety of the families who supplied the children with perished fish and meat. Center for Investigative Journalism managed to identify some of the businessmen who appear in intercepted phone calls and analyzed the companies that
Grand motorsports complex planned in Orhei, for which there is no money
Orhei authorities have announced two years ago about the construction of a European motorsports complex, in the absence of enough money. Almost two million lei were wasted for designing the complex: 1.2 million lei from the national budget and over 600,000 from the district budget, after which the project stopped, because money was not earmarked for the construction. The Court of Auditors found that the design was done in the absence of a feasibility study and the procurement group rejected the company that proposed the lowest price as the selection criterion was breached. As a result, the National Anticorruption
“Sick” procurements in healthcare field
National Agency of Medicines and Medical Devices (AMDM) announces a public tender for supply with necessary medicines for hospitals in 2017. As much as about 500 million lei were earmarked for healthcare field. Center for Investigative Journalism showed in an investigation that, in previous years, public money intended for procurement in Health – about 800 million lei - reached the accounts of seven companies. Four of them were included in 2015 in the blacklist of the Public Procurement Agency, after Moldovan medical institutions faced a drug shortage crisis which, according to authorities, was caused by the boycott of these
Modernization with criminal case at Moldova State University. Illegal tender or attempted political revenge?
Moldova State University (USM) and the construction company Lagmar-Impex SRL started a few years ago a large investment for infrastructure development of the educational institution that would end in 2018. Under the project, the company committed to renovating many dormitories for students and a classroom block. Instead, USM ceded 2 plots in the center of the capital. Here, the company raised a huge residential complex which sells apartments, whose prices start from 444 euros/ 1 square meter. A year ago, the "business" came into sight of Anticorruption prosecutors and officers. The police suspected that the public tender for the
Endless tenders for a project worth 8 million lei
Residents in two villages in district Straseni risk losing a project worth eight million lei, money that was earmarked for the construction of an aqueduct. The tender for selecting the company in charge with works was already organized four times and each time it was challenged by several companies. They disagree that they were disqualified for presenting lower prices than the project’s value. In turn, members of the procurement group say that the law does not allow tenderers to radically decrease the amounts indicated by the designers. The process can be delayed because the appeals are examined in the
Schools with debts of millions on the brink of a new school year
On the brink of the new school year, most schools in Criuleni have debts of thousands of dollars and some -even millions; they are at the risk of reaching the court. The debts date back three years ago when the district authorities have approved a project by which schools were forced to replace all doors and windows. The works were made in advance and the debt was supposed to be paid within 3 years. When the term expired, the company claimed the money which was invested, while headmasters said that they did not have money. The money for project funding
Unprofitable business of the capital
Lands and nonresidential spaces owned by Chisinau Citi Hall is a real godsend for different economic units or people close to local public authorities. Some of them rented spaces with a surface of hundreds of square meters at a price of just seven lei per square meter; others privatized entire buildings at the price required for a dorm room. Although the law requires organizing public tenders for leasing and privatization of lands and buildings in the capital, the authorities avoid this procedure. Thus, public property management, especially of non-residential spaces and lands, is the most damaging activity of the
Councilor-landowner and scandal with plots in Colonita
The mandate of councilor made himself landowner in Colonita. Igor Luchian has recently got 3 plots sold based on a decision of the council which he voted. In addition, in that period he was part of the commission for public tenders. Councilors from the opposition request return of the land to the village and accuse Luchian of conflict of interest. Also, the municipality is charged of "selling" the land based on deals, to people who take advantage of changes in the law, whereby the use of agricultural land can be changed by a vote of the local council and
How was the state deprived of 30 million lei
The state paid 10 million lei for tons of equipment that languishes for years in the stock of an economic unit. The equipment was purchased for a treatment plant, which the authorities in Criuleni have been trying to build it for nearly a decade. The fate of the investment is uncertain while a part of the engineering networks installed were damaged. Meanwhile, the district council pays tens of thousands of dollars annually for storing equipment which nobody knows whether it will ever be used. Works performed by halves The project "Evacuation of waste water from town Criuleni to water treatment
Banned sausages still being served to children in schools and kindergartens
Tons of sausages are still being served to children in schools and kindergartens, despite the discontent of some parents as well as an order of the Ministry of Health which has banned the overfat cold cuts since 2012. The ministry has recently issued another order by which it wishes to indefeasibly take the sausages off the menu in schools and kindergartens since 1st of June. As only a few days are left until then, it is not known whether all the kindergartens will manage to remove the sausages from the menu. The authorities are not in a hurry to
The Authorities of the Capital City, "Eminent" In Squandering Money for Derelict Schools
At least ten schools of Chișinău municipality have been closed over the past years because of the small number of pupils. Beyond the decision about their closedown, the authorities intended to make savings. However, the reality shows that, in the absence of a clear strategy, the buildings of phantom schools still continue to devour millions of lei from the municipal budget. Experts argue that an estimate of the number of pupils and schools should be done and that planning of the use of empty areas should be done based on the respective figures: either to change their destination, or
Road Repair in Chișinău and the Interests of the Mayor Dorin Chirtoacă
The rehabilitation of Stefan cel Mare Boulevard and of Alecsandri and Negruzzi streets in the capital costs us astronomical sums, while the company which executes the works seems to have some relation with Mayor Dorin Chirtoacă. This project aimed at the repair of nearly seven kilometres of road is worth 11.5 million Euros, the money being borrowed. The municipality would have paid a million and a half Euros less, if no infringements were committed at the tender, as confirmed both by the National Integrity Commission, and by a special inquiry commission of Chişinău Municipal Council. The works are being carried
Works Worth Millions Abandoned on the Construction Site at the Presidency Building
The 7th of April 2009 meant scattered hopes and, in the same time, the depletion of the budget by the urge to repair the buildings of the Parliament and of the Presidency destroyed during the violent protests. While the Parliament building was renovated in the meantime, an abandoned construction site lies opposite, at the Presidency building. Under the pressure of the crisis, the renovation works were stopped back in 2011, 106 million lei being spent before that, a sufficient amount for performing half of the works. The authorities have not allocated any funds to preserve the building, therefore at least
Secret Companies and Deals in Rezina
Three companies managed by the same person are the favourites of the authorities of the district of Rezina in terms of public procurements. Every second contract in the field of repairs and constructions was awarded during the period September 2013 - April 2015 to one of the three companies in which Liviu Jitari figures either as a manager, or as a founder: Litarcom, AVI Borș and Capilla. A predilection which arouses suspicion Based on three contracts concluded with Litarcom LLC, the administration of the district of Rezina allocated 2.46 million lei for the renovation of the rooms rented in the premises
Illegal tenders (II)
In a system full of corruption and bribes, in the past two years, only one mayor was caught in the act and then given suspended sentence. He was charged of having frauded a public tender. Though, some tenders seem more than doubtful and the witnesses of some businessmen and mayors reveal a world where the shadow games and the bribes dictate the rules of the game, rules which are accepted by all sides, otherwise, they are excluded from the deal. Continuation No doubt, company Litarcom SRL can be called one of the champions of tenders in the last four years. It won
How the Local Government of Zîrnești Trifles the Public Money Away
The local government of Zîrnești, district of Cahul has compromised a lot of projects with public funds, worth millions of lei. Over one million was thrown away for road renovation, but apart from potholes, nothing can be seen. The House of Culture was renovated, but the roof leaks as before. In the kindergarten, which is equipped with old furniture, everywhere were placed video surveillance cameras, purchased without any tender. To build an agricultural market, the mayoralty hired a relative of the mayor, and dubious schemes were applied during the execution of certain public works. The string of irregularities is
Illegal tenders (I)
In a system full of corruption and bribes, in the past two years, only one mayor was caught in the act and then given suspended sentence. He was charged of having frauded a public tender. Though, some tenders seem more than doubtful and the witnesses of some businessmen and mayors reveal a world where the shadow games and the bribes dictate the rules of the game, rules which are accepted by all sides, otherwise, they are excluded from the deal. In the past years, many Moldovan villages benefited from profitable investment projects. Either it is about the roads reparation, schools
Who dribbles the law in the file of the National Stadium?
The National Stadium situated in the centre of the capital city, where the most important football matches were played in former times, is derelict for almost ten years. In 2006, the Communist governance decided to renovate the sports arena and, without conducting any tender, the company Basconslux was designated to do the demolition, the costs of the works at that stage being estimated at eight million lei. Nevertheless, this company, that was the winner in a number of public tenders, was not paid, although it performed the works. In 2013, after a long correspondence with the authorities, Basconslux started
A former mayor of Peticeni reaped a bakery at the expense of kindergarten children
A group of inhabitants of the village of Peticeni, district of Călăraşi have been struggling for more than a decade for the return of the canteen’s building back to the kindergarten, as, in their opinion, it was illegally alienated. The transaction was done with the consent of the former mayor, and the building became the property of his wife. The case was reported by the villagers on the Corruption Map of Anticoruptie.md website. The kindergarten (left) and the former food unit, today a bakery (right) Photo: CIJM In January 2004, the local council of the village of Peticeni, district of Călăraşi (the
A Dubious Acquisition: How the Town of Cahul Has Got a Defective Snow Removal Machine
The abundant snow fell in the past weeks has disclosed a problematic public procurement made four years ago by the local government of Cahul. Then, the Communist mayor Petru Burlacu concluded, after a public tender, a contract for the purchase of a truck equipped with an anti-skid material spreader with ”Driving LLC”, owned by the daughter of Paul Anton, the leader of the Communist faction in the Town Council of Cahul. The truck, 9 years old, became a pest for sanitation officials. It has never worked properly – it was not in a good technical condition when it was purchased,
The Companies of Oleg Sârbu, Member of Parliament – Favourite Suppliers to State Institutions
Two out of the nine companies owned by the Democrat MP Oleg Sârbu are constant suppliers of food and fuel to three psycho-neurological boarding houses from the northern part of the country, all of which are under the subordination of the Ministry of Labour, Social Protection and Family. Throughout the period 2013-2015, Valentina Buliga, party colleague of Oleg Sârbu, was at the head of this ministry. The former minister says she has not influenced anyhow the tenders. The fact is that the respective companies, alongside with a third one, specialized in fuel sale, supplied to State institutions goods and
Tenders for the family of the Director of the Public Procurement Agency
The company owned by the Director of the Public Procurement Agency won in the last 2 years tenders’ worth 35 million lei, managed by the state institution. Most of lucrative tenders won by this company have been challenged by competitors, but in most cases, the Agency’s representatives have dismissed the claims of economic units. Business partners and the family of the Head of Public Procurement Agency have been successful at tenders in recent years, winning contracts worth tens of millions of lei. The building where is located Public Procurement Agency. Photo: CIJM Viorel Mosneaga was appointed deputy director at the Public Procurement
A Project for the Dump of Bubuieci Compromised by the Interests
The amount of 4 million lei, allocated 3 years ago by the National Ecological Fund (NEF) to the local government of Bubuieci for the purchase of two mobile stations for construction waste processing, has become a matter of prosecutorial investigation. The General Prosecutor’s Office (GP) has initiated a penal case for embezzlement, by virtue of art. 191 of the Penal Code, and the prosecution is now underway. The GP’s Office informed us about it in the response to an inquiry. In fact, nobody knows who exactly is prosecuted – the former members of NEF Board of Directors who disbursed
Millions of the City Hall “buried” in 41 yards in Chisinau
The arrangement of some yards in Chisinau and creation of some thousands parking spaces, which the mayor Dorin Chirtoaca praised in the summing up for 2015, cost 53,3 million lei, an unjustified sum, say experts. Moreover, the purchasing agreement of these works was concluded with some procedural violations. The agreement signed between the City Hall and the company that performed the works, Lucet-comert is unclear. The document does not stipulate the exact number of yards and parking spaces to be arranged and does not show the addresses where the works are performed. Though this company has not fully completed its
Schools in Taraclia, obliged to allocate one million lei for equipment they don’t need
Taraclia Rayon Council has allocated about one million lei for useless equipment - heat generators for the sports halls of the Rayon gymnasiums and lyceums. At the same time, the school managers say the money had to be spent on works which are more necessary, the councilors state that they have thought about the pupils’ health. The “deal” has been made without resorting to public procurement, being promoted by the former head of Rayon and unanimously voted by the Rayon councilors. The money for the heating sources has been used from the so-called Rayon component for education, a joint school
Vladimir Molojen was acquitted after he enriched his family’s company during his tenure
Vladimir Molojen (69), former Minister of Information Development, concluded public contracts estimated at over two million lei with the company of his family seven years ago. He was acquitted on December 9th, by the Buiucani District Court in the capital, though the anticorruption prosecutor ruled six years in prison. The judgment was delivered by the court president, Dorin Dolghier. The prosecution took a year and a half, and then the trial was in the court for 4 years. Since then, the prosecutor of this case Mihail Ivanov, warned several times that the examination was delayed deliberately. He enriched his family’s
The stories from www.anticoruptie.md may be used in the limit of up to 1,000 characters. Web pages must indicate the source and link directly to the article. Print media, Radio and TV stations must indicate the source. Publishing full version of stories is allowed based on a prior agreement with the Center for Investigative Journalism. Articles published on www.anticoruptie.md are protected by the Law on copyright and related rights of Republic of Moldova.